#189 - Attack Ideas, Not People

“Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.”Amendment I, The U.S. Constitution

“Without Freedom of Thought, there can be no such thing as Wisdom; and no such thing as public liberty, without Freedom of Speech.”Benjamin Franklin, Letter from Silence Dogood, printed in The New England Courant, July 9, 1722

“Reason and free inquiry are the only effectual agents against error.”Thomas Jefferson

“In those wretched countries where a man cannot call his tongue his own, he can scarce call anything his own. Whoever would overthrow the liberty of a nation must begin by subduing the freeness of speech; a thing terrible to publick traytors.”Benjamin Franklin, Dogood Papers, written by Franklin in 1722, at the age of sixteen

Freedom of speech is not merely the right to say what is popular, agreeable, or comfortable — it is the obligation to defend the right of others to speak even when what they say is offensive, repulsive, or factually incorrect. True freedom of speech means tolerating words that may make us angry, upset, or uncomfortable, because the alternative is far more dangerous: a society where only approved speech is permitted.

We must defend freedom of speech vigorously — or the very foundation of our nation will begin to dissolve. This means defending others’ rights to speak especially when they disagree with us. The real test of free speech is not in protecting the voices that echo our own views, but in protecting those that challenge, provoke, or even offend us.

Central to this principle is the freedom to debate ideas on their merit without taking personal offense. If every disagreement becomes an attack on one’s dignity, dialogue collapses into hostility. The health of a free society depends on our ability to divorce someone’s ideas from their worth as a person. Critiquing a belief or argument is not the same as attacking the individual who holds it. When we begin to equate a person’s identity with their ideas, we close off the possibility of persuasion, growth, and mutual understanding.

Freedom of speech must be protected at all costs, because it is the only mechanism by which society moves toward a greater collective truth. Progress is forged in the open marketplace of ideas, where good arguments rise and bad ones are exposed and discarded. Stifling speech may silence offensive voices, but it also silences dissent, innovation, and discovery.

Charlie Kirk has been a lightning rod for controversy — offensive to some, a hero to others. But what matters most is not whether one agrees with him but that he stood for the most important principle in a free nation: the right to speak, to be heard, and to have one’s ideas tested in the public square. Like the ancient saying, “the blood of the martyrs is the seed of the church,” his life reminds us that those willing to endure criticism, hostility, and even personal cost for the sake of truth sow the seeds for the freedoms future generations will enjoy. With his passing, his life’s work will continue to live on beyond himself as one who defended our nation’s most foundational principle.

Without this freedom, America would cease to be the America envisioned by its founders. Our nation is defined not by unanimity of thought, but by the courage to let ideas clash, trusting that truth will emerge stronger on the other side. The task falls to each of us to carry forward that mission, to debate openly, to defend the right to speak — not just for ourselves, but for those we may most strongly oppose — so that liberty remains the lifeblood of this nation.

Investor’s Corner

Peter Lynch’s investment checklist - Link

Investing in wide moat businesses - link

Dev Kantesaria’s returns are pretty incredible - Link

Interview between Jim Grant and Dev Kantesaria - Link

Technology Corner

The new status game: longevity - Link

Where is AI taking us? Sam Altman + Vinod Khosla - Link

Cloudy with a loss of spending control - how data centers are endangering state budgets - Link

Politics, Philosophy, Theology Corner

The Fed’s new ‘gain of function’ monetary policy - Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent - Link

How to Save America: Mark Cuban and Tucker Carlson Debate | All-In Summit 2025 - Link

St. Augustine on reading Scripture - Link

Senator Rand Paul on tariffs and a warning for America - Link

Michael Knowles on all things Trump, tariffs, Israel, and why Christianity is making a return in America - Link

The US population could fall for the first time ever in 2025 - Link